Below is an excerpt from our bi-weekly internal company newsletter:
Industry News:
Franchise Fever: Who Is Recruiting New Talent
Overview: While most businesses are struggling due to the recession; many franchises are steadily growing. Franchised businesses currently make up 11% of the U.S. economy and take in 41% of every dollar spent – in past recessions, franchises actually saw growth. With the cost of opening a franchise ranging anywhere between $20,000 and $350,000, locating new franchisees is a challenge for most franchisors, especially with the struggling economy. Some suggestions for franchisors trying to attract new franchisees: offer free kiosks, waive the first year royalty fee, think green, etc.
Balihoo Perspective: While this list doesn’t go deeply into any of the franchise businesses they identify, it does shine some light on the whole give-and-take mentality that franchisors need to embrace in order to attract new franchisees. One significant area that franchisors should consider helping their franchisees with is marketing. Franchisors should ask themselves if they provide a marketing platform that serves as a point of competitive advantage – do they help their franchisees market locally and do they do it well enough to attract new franchisees?
RAB: Radio Accountability Initiative Introduced
Overview: To improve radio’s accountability with advertisers, the Radio Advertising Bureau is throwing its support behind Ad-ID, the
commercial identification system supported and authorized by the American Association of Advertising Agencies and the Association of National Advertisers. The ‘Radio Accountability Initiative’ will help ensure that an advertiser’s commercials get on the right radio outlets at the right time.“As radio aims to grow its share of ad dollars, proof of performance, improved commercial workflow and consumer interactivity are increasingly important at the station level. It is beneficial to make radio commercials as interactive as the purchase-enabled songs to which they are attached,” said Jeff Haley, president and CEO for the RAB.
Balihoo Perspective: Radio advertising offers some great advantages: less expensive than TV, usually hits a captive audience (in the car), power of repetition, etc. However, radio ads can also be too short and might fail to reach their target audience (both vary with the advertised brand and its target audience). Accurate reporting is something that has ailed radio advertisers for years – discovering a solid reporting/tracking system would undoubtedly help radio stations and their advertisers.
The Persistent Gap in Integrated Media Planning
Overview: Marketers are still struggling to successfully integrate their campaigns. More than ever, marketers need to be able to analyze and evaluate all media in one place to enable easier optimization and attain greater insight. The overall conclusion in this article is that it is time for “someone” to develop a multi-platform integrated media solution. iMedia Brand Summit survey showed that:
- 41% of marketers say that coordinating marketing efforts across internal departments (brand, promotions, sports marketing, etc.) is often difficult
- 39% of marketers find it tough to negotiate efficient cross-platform deals with publishers and media companies
- 38% find it difficult to field campaigns across multiple media channels35% find it tough to get different agencies to collaborate together.
Balihoo Perspective: To solve this problem, marketers need a solution that allows for the easy creation and management of an integrated communications plan. Holistic campaign visibility, measurement, optimization and ROI can all be enhanced for both franchisors and their franchisees through the use of a multi-platform integrated media solution such as our own. While medium-specific tools (TV, radio, online, digital out-of-home, etc.) add efficiency to the buying process, they fail to solve the larger issue of streamlining both the inventory management of media properties or offering fully integrated marketing solutions for brands with clear, consistent and connected messaging designed to reinforce the national brand.
10 Area Eateries Employ 290 Workers: Jack in the Box Franchise Owner Michael Norwich Excels
Overview: Michael Norwich, winner of the 2007 U.S Small Business Administration’s Small Business Person of the Year award, explains how he took over his father’s struggling Jack in the Box, turned it around and then went on to open 10 restaurants and employ over 290 people. Interestingly, Norwich doesn’t praise Jack in the Box’s corporate marketing model. “We have a little bit different business model than even corporate Jack in the Box. I believe that the Jack in the Box brand is a little bit of a destination. I don’t consider myself to be as convenience-driven, so we don’t try to penetrate the market as much as corporate Jack in the Box does. I like to draw on larger trade areas.”
Balihoo Perspective: While Michael Norwich says he doesn’t completely adhere to the corporate Jack in the Box business model and doesn’t try “to penetrate the market as much as corporate Jack in the Box does” it is important to really think about why he can do this successfully – I would argue that corporate Jack in the Box’s strong, penetrating national advertising is the very backbone to Norwich’s preferred ‘soft sell’ approach. Without strong brand awareness generated at the national level, it would be more difficult for Norwich to focus solely on connecting with his local customers (who already have a conceived notion of what the brand stands for). Norwich’s focus on connecting with his local customer base is what franchisees should be encouraged to focused on – franchisors need to ensure that they give their affiliates the tools to do so properly.
McDonald’s Franchisees Take Online Marketing Into Own Hands
Overview: McDonald’s franchisees in southern California recently launched a website to drive local coffee drinkers to their restaurants. The
website, www.mcdonaldssocal.com, provides Southern California customers with a way to locate ‘McCafes’, local community activities
(involving McDonalds) and menu changes.
Balihoo Perspective: This is a great example of how franchisees can generate local interest. What is key about this franchisee-developed website, packed with local community information and activities, is that it is completely in-concert with the national brand. Thus, remaining closely tied to the national image while also zeroing in locally (by featuring a community calendar of events). For a franchise as highly recognized as McDonald’s building a sense of community between each individual restaurant and its local customer base is understandably difficult – this website is a great way to forge a connection.
Analyst: Google, Myspace Make a Bad Fit
Overview: Suggests that social networking platforms are gradually making search less relevant. Pali Reseach analyst, Richard Greenfield notes internet users’ growing inclination to search for specific information by tapping into friends’ and colleague’s knowledge through platforms like Twitter’s own search product, as well Facebook’s status update tool. To boost revenue, Greenfield recommends that MySpace continue to expand its portal-like ad strategy, which has proven successful in attracting major advertisers to its home page and music channels.
Balihoo Perspective: Chances are you are involved in some form of social networking. Have you found yourself using social networking for search – has social networking led you to discover new information that you may or may not have been ‘searching for’. Do you think social networking has the capability to really compete with the large search engines? I have found myself using Twitter’s search feature more and more when it comes to current topics, issues or discussions – however, when it comes to anything historical or dare I say factual, I feel more comfortable researching through a search engine (Google).
When Career Turns Down, Franchising is an Option
Overview: More and more laid off workers are considering franchising as an alternative to working for someone else. Some see franchising as an easy way to entrepreneurship and economic independence. But becoming a successful franchisee takes a lot of hard work and money. This article goes into some things potential franchise owners should consider before taking the plunge.
Balihoo Perspective: Overall, the number one thing any potential franchisee should do is their homework – once it is done, do it over again. Owning a franchise is a lot of work and requires someone who is entrepreneurially spirited, committed and very knowledgeable of the industry they are going into. Make sure that you identify with the franchise corporation that you are considering joining and that it has a solid business plan, solid branding support and an integrated marketing plan, if they don’t keep looking until you find one that does.
The In-Store Strategy
Overview: With the economy down, many in the quick-service restaurant (QSR) industry are embracing POP advertising more than ever.
Brands such as Wendy’s, Five Guys, Checkers and Dunkin’ brands (which has over 6,000 locations across the U.S) say they will not be reducing in-store advertising at all. With 20 to 30% of marketing dollars going to waste every year because brands haven’t invested in specific customization for their location(s), it is more important than ever to make sure you are fully customizing your marketing materials. Dan Wittner, chief customer officer for RBM, says that in the midst of this economic climate, efficiency is just as important as consistency. “The first thing you have to do in this kind of economy is get smarter about every dollar you are spending, Wittner says. “We’re talking to a number of quick-service restaurant groups right now, and we’re going to get them organized around their individual restaurants’ attributes.”
Balihoo Perspective: POP is a very important part of the marketing mix. Franchisees need to have the necessary tools to fully customize their in-store advertising in order to maximize their ROI. Pulling back on POP right now is an awful idea – both for the national brand and the brand’s local presence.
Banks are Killing the Next Big Thing
Overview: Even Facebook is struggling to get a loan. Having raised $500 million in equity and debt financing without producing a profit, Facebook is continually working on growing their revenue and their advertising. “Venture capital is suffering right alongside commercial lenders. In a recent survey, law firm Fenwick & West found that, of 128 companies that received venture funding last quarter, one-third had to accept new money at a lower valuation. The rub? VCs are too pinched to take chances.”
Balihoo Perspective: Interesting time indeed. While Facebook is nearly as recognizable today as Google and is most commonly hailed as a “success story”, it is struggling to get additional funding. With the recession and loan crisis, it has never been more important to generate profit – even for nationally recognized “successful” and “accomplished” companies.